patent novelty check
- Repo stars 11,320
- Author repo Auto-claude-code-research-in-sleep
- Domain
- Engineering
- Author-declared agents
- No explicit declaration found; this is not inferred or tested compatibility
- Static check
- 88 / 100 · heuristic scan, not runtime safety proof
- Runtime evidence
- Not run; no isolated runtime test evidence is currently recorded
- Author / version / license
- @wanshuiyin · no license declared
- Token usage
- Lean
- Setup complexity
- Plug-and-play
- External API key
- Not required
- Operating systems
- Unspecified (assume cross-platform)
- Runtime requirements
- No explicit requirements detected
- Detected file/system behavior
-
- Read-only
- Write / modify
- Network behavior
- Local-only
- Install commands
- None (reference only)
Heads up: Tool permissions are not declared; actual access depends on the runtime.
# Step 6: Output
Write `patent/NOVELTY_ASSESSMENT.md`: ```markdown From the invention description, extract the key claim elements that would define the invention's scope: List the technical features that make the invention novel Identify which features are known from prior art vs. inventive Draft preliminary claim language for 2-3 independent claims (method + system)
For each preliminary claim, test against EACH prior art reference in `PRIOR_ART_REPORT.md`: Single-reference test: Does any single reference disclose ALL claim elements? Claim Element · Ref 1 · Ref 2 · Ref 3 · ... Feature A · Yes/No + evidence Feature B · Yes/No + evidence
If the invention is novel (passes Step 2), test for obviousness: Two/three-reference combination test: Can 2-3 references be combined to render the claim obvious? For each combination of the top references: Primary reference: Which reference is closest to the claimed invention? Secondary reference(s): Which reference(s) teach the missing element(s)?
Call `REVIEWER_MODEL` via `mcp__codex__codex` with xhigh reasoning:
For each target jurisdiction, provide a patentability assessment: Under 35 USC 102/103 (US): Novelty: PASS / FAIL (cite specific reference if fail) Non-obviousness: PASS / FAIL (cite combination if fail) Under Article 22 CN Patent Law (CN):
Write `patent/NOVELTY_ASSESSMENT.md`:
# Patent Novelty and Non-Obviousness Check
Assess patentability of: **$ARGUMENTS**
Adapted from `/novelty-check` for patent legal standards. Research novelty is NOT the same as patent novelty.
## Constants
- `REVIEWER_MODEL = gpt-5.5` — Model used via Codex MCP for cross-model examiner verification
- `NOVELTY_STANDARD = patent` — Always use legal patentability standard, not research contribution standard
## Inputs
1. Invention description from `$ARGUMENTS`
2. `patent/PRIOR_ART_REPORT.md` (output of `/prior-art-search`)
3. `patent/INVENTION_BRIEF.md` if exists
## Shared References
Load `../shared-references/patent-writing-principles.md` for novelty/non-obviousness standards.
Load `../shared-references/patent-format-us.md` for 102/103 analysis framework.
## Workflow
### Step 1: Define Claim Elements
From the invention description, extract the key claim elements that would define the invention's scope:
1. List the technical features that make the invention novel
2. Identify which features are known from prior art vs. inventive
3. Draft preliminary claim language for 2-3 independent claims (method + system)
### Step 2: Anticipation Analysis (Novelty)
For each preliminary claim, test against EACH prior art reference in `PRIOR_ART_REPORT.md`:
**Single-reference test**: Does any single reference disclose ALL claim elements?
| Claim Element | Ref 1 | Ref 2 | Ref 3 | ... |
|--------------|-------|-------|-------|-----|
| Feature A | Yes/No + evidence | | | |
| Feature B | Yes/No + evidence | | | |
| Feature C | Yes/No + evidence | | | |
| Feature D | Yes/No + evidence | | | |
**Verdict per reference**:
- ANTICIPATED: One reference discloses every element → claim is not novel
- NOT ANTICIPATED: At least one element missing from every single reference → claim is novel
### Step 3: Obviousness Analysis (Inventive Step)
If the invention is novel (passes Step 2), test for obviousness:
**Two/three-reference combination test**: Can 2-3 references be combined to render the claim obvious?
For each combination of the top references:
1. **Primary reference**: Which reference is closest to the claimed invention?
2. **Secondary reference(s)**: Which reference(s) teach the missing element(s)?
3. **Motivation to combine**: Would a POSITA have reason to combine these references?
- Explicit suggestion in the references themselves?
- Same field, same problem?
- Common design incentive?
- Known technique for improving similar devices?
Format as a matrix:
| Combination | Primary | Secondary | Missing Elements | Motivation to Combine | Obvious? |
|-------------|---------|-----------|-----------------|----------------------|----------|
| Ref1 + Ref2 | Ref1 | Ref2 | Feature D | Same field, similar problem | Yes/No |
### Step 4: Cross-Model Examiner Verification
Call `REVIEWER_MODEL` via `mcp__codex__codex` with xhigh reasoning:
```
mcp__codex__codex:
config: {"model_reasoning_effort": "xhigh"}
prompt: |
You are a senior patent examiner at the [USPTO/CNIPA/EPO].
Examine the following invention for patentability.
INVENTION: [invention description + preliminary claims]
PRIOR ART: [prior art references with key teachings]
Please analyze:
1. Anticipation (novelty): Does any single reference anticipate any claim?
2. Obviousness: Can any combination of references render claims obvious?
3. Claim scope: Are the claims broad enough to be valuable?
4. Recommended amendments if any claim is rejected.
Be rigorous and cite specific references.
```
### Step 5: Jurisdiction-Specific Assessment
For each target jurisdiction, provide a patentability assessment:
**Under 35 USC 102/103 (US)**:
- Novelty: PASS / FAIL (cite specific reference if fail)
- Non-obviousness: PASS / FAIL (cite combination if fail)
**Under Article 22 CN Patent Law (CN)**:
- 新颖性 (Novelty): 通过 / 未通过
- 创造性 (Inventive Step): 通过 / 未通过
**Under Article 54/56 EPC (EP)**:
- Novelty: PASS / FAIL
- Inventive step: PASS / FAIL (problem-solution approach)
### Step 6: Output
Write `patent/NOVELTY_ASSESSMENT.md`:
```markdown
## Patentability Assessment
### Invention Summary
[description]
### Overall Assessment
[PATENTABLE / PATENTABLE WITH AMENDMENTS / NOT PATENTABLE]
### Anticipation Analysis
[claim-by-claim matrix against each reference]
### Obviousness Analysis
[combination analysis with motivation to combine]
### Cross-Model Examiner Review
[summary of GPT-5.5 examiner feedback]
### Recommended Claim Amendments
[If claims need modification to overcome prior art, suggest specific amendments]
### Risk Factors
[What could cause rejection during actual prosecution?]
```
## Key Rules
- Patent novelty is absolute: any public disclosure before the priority date counts as prior art, worldwide.
- Research novelty ("has anyone published this?") is NOT the same as patent novelty ("does any single reference teach every claim element?").
- Obviousness requires BOTH: (1) a combination of references AND (2) a motivation to combine them.
- Never assume the invention is patentable just because no identical patent exists.
- The assessment is advisory only -- actual prosecution may reveal different prior art.
- If `mcp__codex__codex` is not available, skip cross-model examiner review and note it in the output.
Listed in source order.
sections -> Constants → Inputs → Shared References → Workflow → Step 1: Define Claim Elements → Step 2: Anticipation Analysis (Novelty)
terms -> $ARGUMENTS · Single-reference test · Verdict per reference · Two/three-reference combination test · Primary reference · Secondary reference(s) · Motivation to combine · Under 35 USC 102/103 (US)
files/cmd -> /novelty-check · REVIEWER_MODEL = gpt-5.5 · NOVELTY_STANDARD = patent · $ARGUMENTS · patent/PRIOR_ART_REPORT.md · /prior-art-search · patent/INVENTION_BRIEF.md · ../shared-references/patent-writing-principles.md
body sha256 -> 20d4664407fc
Constants
REVIEWER_MODEL = gpt-5.5— Model used via Codex MCP for cross-model examiner verificationNOVELTY_STANDARD = patent— Always use legal patentability standard, not research contribution standardInputs
Invention description from
$ARGUMENTSpatent/PRIOR_ART_REPORT.md(output of/prior-art-search)patent/INVENTION_BRIEF.mdif existsShared References
Load
../shared-references/patent-writing-principles.mdfor novelty/non-obviousness standards. Load../shared-references/patent-format-us.mdfor 102/103 analysis framework.Step 1: Define Claim Elements
From the invention description, extract the key claim elements that would define the invention's scope: List the technical features that make the invention novel Identify which features are known from prior art vs. inventive Draft preliminary claim language for 2-3 independent claims (method + system)
Step 2: Anticipation Analysis (Novelty)
For each preliminary claim, test against EACH prior art reference in
PRIOR_ART_REPORT.md: Single-reference test: Does any single reference disclose ALL claim elements? Claim Element · Ref 1 · Ref 2 · Ref 3 · ... Feature A · Yes/No + evidence Feature B · Yes/No + evidence