pr review
- Repo stars 184,730
- Author repo AutoGPT
- Domain
- Security
- Author-declared agents
- No explicit declaration found; this is not inferred or tested compatibility
- Static check
- 88 / 100 · heuristic scan, not runtime safety proof
- Runtime evidence
- Not run; no isolated runtime test evidence is currently recorded
- Author / version / license
- @Significant-Gravitas · no license declared
- Token usage
- Lean
- Setup complexity
- Plug-and-play
- External API key
- Not required
- Operating systems
- Unspecified (assume cross-platform)
- Runtime requirements
- No explicit requirements detected
- Detected file/system behavior
-
- Read-only
- Write / modify
- Network behavior
- External requests
- Install commands
- None (reference only)
Heads up: Tool permissions are not declared; actual access depends on the runtime.
# PR Review
## Find the PR
```bash
gh pr list --head $(git branch --show-current) --repo Significant-Gravitas/AutoGPT
gh pr view {N}
```
## Read the PR description
Before reading code, understand the **why**, **what**, and **how** from the PR description:
```bash
gh pr view {N} --json body --jq '.body'
```
Every PR should have a Why / What / How structure. If any of these are missing, note it as feedback.
## Read the diff
```bash
gh pr diff {N}
```
## Fetch existing review comments
Before posting anything, fetch existing inline comments to avoid duplicates:
```bash
gh api repos/Significant-Gravitas/AutoGPT/pulls/{N}/comments --paginate
gh api repos/Significant-Gravitas/AutoGPT/pulls/{N}/reviews
```
## What to check
**Description quality:** Does the PR description cover Why (motivation/problem), What (summary of changes), and How (approach/implementation details)? If any are missing, request them — you can't judge the approach without understanding the problem and intent.
**Correctness:** logic errors, off-by-one, missing edge cases, race conditions (TOCTOU in file access, credit charging), error handling gaps, async correctness (missing `await`, unclosed resources).
**Security:** input validation at boundaries, no injection (command, XSS, SQL), secrets not logged, file paths sanitized (`os.path.basename()` in error messages).
**Code quality:** apply rules from backend/frontend CLAUDE.md files.
**Architecture:** DRY, single responsibility, modular functions. `Security()` vs `Depends()` for FastAPI auth. `data:` for SSE events, `: comment` for heartbeats. `transaction=True` for Redis pipelines.
**Testing:** edge cases covered, colocated `*_test.py` (backend) / `__tests__/` (frontend), mocks target where symbol is **used** not defined, `AsyncMock` for async.
## Output format
Every comment **must** be prefixed with `🤖` and a criticality badge:
| Tier | Badge | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Blocker | `🔴 **Blocker**` | Must fix before merge |
| Should Fix | `🟠 **Should Fix**` | Important improvement |
| Nice to Have | `🟡 **Nice to Have**` | Minor suggestion |
| Nit | `🔵 **Nit**` | Style / wording |
Example: `🤖 🔴 **Blocker**: Missing error handling for X — suggest wrapping in try/except.`
## Post inline comments
For each finding, post an inline comment on the PR (do not just write a local report):
```bash
# Get the latest commit SHA for the PR
COMMIT_SHA=$(gh api repos/Significant-Gravitas/AutoGPT/pulls/{N} --jq '.head.sha')
# Post an inline comment on a specific file/line
gh api repos/Significant-Gravitas/AutoGPT/pulls/{N}/comments \
-f body="🤖 🔴 **Blocker**: <description>" \
-f commit_id="$COMMIT_SHA" \
-f path="<file path>" \
-F line=<line number>
```
Sections and files
Listed in source order.
sections -> Find the PR → Read the PR description → Read the diff → Fetch existing review comments → What to check → Output format
terms -> why · what · how · Description quality · Correctness · Security · Code quality · Architecture
files/cmd -> await · os.path.basename() · Security() · Depends() · data: · : comment · transaction=True · *_test.py
body sha256 -> 55cad1260d20
Read the PR description
Before reading code, understand the why, what, and how from the PR description: Every PR should have a Why / What / How structure. If any of these are missing, note it as feedback.
Fetch existing review comments
Before posting anything, fetch existing inline comments to avoid duplicates:
What to check
Description quality: Does the PR description cover Why (motivation/problem), What (summary of changes), and How (approach/implementation details)? If any are missing, request them — you can't judge the approach without understanding the problem and intent. Correctness: logic errors, off-by-one, missing edge cases, race conditions (TOCTOU in file access, credit charging), error handling gaps, async correctness (missing
await, unclosed resources).Output format
Every comment must be prefixed with
🤖and a criticality badge: Tier · Badge · Meaning Blocker ·🔴 Blocker· Must fix before merge Should Fix ·🟠 Should Fix· Important improvement Nice to Have ·🟡 Nice to Have· Minor suggestionPost inline comments
For each finding, post an inline comment on the PR (do not just write a local report):